10 Best Coffee Maker Reviews & Buyer’s Guide – 2019

10 Best Coffee Maker Reviews & Buyer’s Guide – 2019

Best Coffee Maker

Most coffee makers that cost a coin are capable of brewing good coffee. The most important thing here is that the temperature that the water has after it has warmed up is hot enough to break down the taste and aromas in the coffee. 

Among the various useful tips on how to choose a traditional coffee maker it is important to check that it can be used both on gas stoves and on other plates, for example, those in glass-ceramic, radiant or induction, and check whether the various elements that constitute it can be washed in the dishwasher or by hand only.

On the market, in addition to the classic stainless steel or aluminum coffee maker, there are products with a metal base and filter and a ceramic or transparent glass tank. the handle is generally made of plastic and, in many models, can be replaced (exactly like the filter and the gasket) in case of damage or breakage.

In this review article, you can read more about a number of different tests of coffee makers and we will show you the test winners from both American and European tests. Our goal is to collect all relevant tests here so that you can easily create an overview of which coffee makers are recommended in independent tests.

Recommended For You:

ImageCoffee MakerCapacityrating 

Redline MK1 Coffee Brewer

64 oz

4.9/5

Check Price

Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed

60 oz

4.6/5

Check Price

Single-Serve K-Cup Coffee Maker

60 oz

4.8/5

Check Price

Deluxe Coffee and Espresso Machine

40 oz

4.9/5

Check Price

Kenmore Elite Coffee Maker

84 oz

4.5/5

Check Price

Nespresso Evoluo Espresso Machine

54 oz

4.7/5

Check Price


Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Pod

75 oz

4.6/5

Check Price

Nespresso Vertuo Coffee Machine

40 oz

4.7/5

Check Price

Nespresso Coffee and Espresso Machine

54 oz

4.2/5

Check Price

SharkNinja CF091 Coffee Makers

50 oz

4.9/5

Check Price

1. Redline MK1 8 Cup Coffee Brewer with Glass Carafe

Redline MK1 Coffee Maker

Redline’s vision is to create world-class coffee products that are infused with vintage car design. The MK1 brews a great pot of coffee. With its powerful heating element, it reaches optimum brew temperatures between 195-205 degrees Fahrenheit and can complete a full brew cycle in 6 minutes. The coffee maker is super fast and super hot. The 8 cup VS 12 cup makes it even faster to get your coffee up. It’s a great unit that is easy to use and clean.

The glass carafe is completely clear, no markings or words at all. All of the markings for water level are on the water reserve tank to the side. Though the entire reservoir does not detach from the main body of the machine, the entire lid covering the reservoir does. Once the lid is removed, you can pour water into the reservoir, which opens quite wide allowing for an easy pouring experience.

The “Parking Brake” drip lever allows you to open or “pause” your brew and even fine-tune the rate of your drip. High boron glass carafe with insulated funnel for even distribution of fresh coffee throughout your pot for a consistent taste from start to finish.

It’s simple to use. There’s only one button, and only one option. If you don’t want to spend big bucks, and you don’t have to have a timer or a thermal carafe, I would highly recommend the Redline coffee brewer.
Pros
  • It came with a few paper filters, uses standard paper or a reusable screen type filters.
  • It’s extremely well made, brews at a temperature that makes coffee Perfect.
  • The carafe does not leak.
  • There are ridges so the coffee is extracted more evenly.
  • Makes a full pot in around 6 minutes with pre-infusion.
Cons
  • The unit is 11.5 inches long, not 9.25 inches.

Check Price On Amazon

2. Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System – Auto-iQ Tea and Coffee Maker

Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System

The set up is well thought out. You put about a half gallon or so of water in the tank on the right side of the unit. There is a thermal carafe that you can use with it that is stainless steel of you want a pot of coffee or tea. The screen on the front is dark until you push the power button and it lights up.

You use the top dial to choose what you want to make and what strength, and then you can opt for tea and those settings as well.

The measure cup has coffee settings on one side and tea on the flip side. There is a large and small cup on each end. This fits onto the side of the unit out of the way when not in use. These clues the machine into which you are making. It is easy to put on and tuck into the unit.

The milk frother is on a retractable arm which you can put warmed or cold milk in a cup on the side and power it up to froth the milk. It works decently and does foam up. You can remove the unit for cleaning.

Another feature I forgot to mention is that there is a little shelf that flips down so you can make a mug of tea or coffee. You can also make a travel mug direction under the machine even up to XL size. Then if you want to make the carafe you can flip up the shelf and put the carafe in there.

This unit is not too large, but nor is it small. It takes up some room on the counter, but it is compact considering what it does! A “specialty” button for espresso and chai type coffees and teas. There’s a calibrating button and a cleaning button.
Pros
  • It works decently and does foam up.
  • The filters are easy to clean and fast too.
  • Makes hot and cold drinks that can be “classic” or “rich”
  • Makes a great pot of coffee and can also brew tea.
  • Has an innovative design to ensure your tea doesn’t taste like coffee.
Cons
  • It is pricey for a device that dumps water over coffee beans.

Check Price On Amazon

3. Keurig K-Cafe Single-Serve K-Cup Coffee Maker

K-Cup Coffee Maker

The K-Cafe coffee, latte, and cappuccino maker is one of the latest brewer innovations from Keurig. With the K-Café coffee maker, you can brew your favorite coffee or make creamy lattes and frothy cappuccinos using any K-Cup pod. Keurig’s line of Espresso Roast K-Cup pods pair perfectly with the special features of the Keurig K-Café coffee maker.

It large 60oz water reservoir allows you to brew 6 cups before having to refill, saving you time and simplifying your morning routine. The Strong button is an optional feature that can be selected for a stronger, more robust cup of coffee.

You can pull your coffee and froth milk at the same time. It does need to heat up completely before it will do both. You’ll know because you press the button to froth and it won’t do anything. Just be patient and it’ll start frothing when the machine is ready.

There’s a setting for Coffee or Latte/Capo. By selecting the Latte/Capo button, the machine automatically selects “STRONG” and “SHOT”. It knows what you want and sets it up for you. For cappuccino. And for a Keurig, this is as close to the real deal as you’re going to get without an authentic, steam-injected machine.

The mug clearance with drip tray is 6 inches. With the drip tray removed the clearance is 7.2 inches. It will automatically turn off 2 hours after the last brew. You can disable the auto-off feature if you wish to keep the coffee maker on all the time.
Pros
  • Brewing times are very efficient and clean-up is very simple.
  • The water reservoir is easy to handle, refill and reinstall.
  • Install the filter to the water vessel, add water and you’re good to go.
  • You can use any K-Cup in this machine.
  • The design is smartly efficient and very good looking.
Cons
  • The K-Cafe Coffee Maker is intended for home use only and is not NSF certified.

Check Price On Amazon

4. Nespresso Vertuo Coffee Machine – Aeroccino Milk Frother

Nespresso Vertuo Coffee Maker

Each machine includes a welcome set with 12 Nespresso Vertuo capsules containing individual aromas. Nespresso Experts have created these highly aromatic and smooth gourmet blends, individually developed to deliver ultimate quality. The result is 26 incomparable Nespresso coffee experiences, each carefully balanced and roasted to bring out its unique flavor profile. 

Nespresso is a single-serve machine, like Keurig. The Nespresso coffee pods have bar codes on the rim. When you put your pod into the machine and start the brew the pod is spun and the machine reads the barcode. It’s simple to use and you can find myriad recipes online. Of course for those hot summer days you can make an iced coffee drink as well.

You can only use the Nespresso pods. These machines will not work unless they have the Nespresso pods in them – they are designed to “read” the Nespresso pods to give you the right amount of water for that specific pod.
Pros
  • Froth is excellent – no brainer, separate milk and froth by spoon.
  • It has two settings, one for if the milk is cold.
  • It makes a nice froth, and shuts off automagically.
  • When finished, the pods dispose of themselves in the little bucket to the right!
  • The machine automatically knows the right amount of water from the pod.
Cons
  • The Nespresso machine only uses the Nespresso capsules.
  • The pod options are limited.

Check Price On Amazon

5. Kenmore Elite 76772 12-Cup Drip Best Coffee Maker

Kenmore Elite 76772 Coffee Maker

This Kenmore Elite 12-cup coffee maker keeps you smiling with every sip. The stainless steel exterior lends sleek appeal while 24-hour programmability and an easy pour carafe with a comfort grip handle help to simplify your morning routine. The kettle range is from a minimum of 110 degrees F to 212 degrees F. The lowest temperature setting is 110 degrees, and the max is 212 degrees. It allows settings in 10-degree increments from 110-200. This is small but not considered travel size.

The lid is hinged within this diameter so from front to hinge on the back it is about 3 inches. The Kenmore 40704 has an automatic shut off after 2 hrs. and signal shutoff with 5 long beeps. No leaks when you pour the coffee. Plenty of room to fill the reservoir. And that pesky loud beep is no longer that loud. I would definitely recommend this coffee maker to my friends.

This coffee maker has a plastic water reservoir. The coffeemaker exterior is wrapped in stainless steel. The grounds basket is composed of a plastic basket with a gold-tone screen. The difference between an Elite & Regular appliance are the features and the design. The Elite is a step up from a regular appliance.

Parts come off to clean easily, but the design of the coffee maker around the brewing compartment make for cleaning to be a bit more difficult than you might experience on a standard no frills coffee maker.
Pros
  • It doesn’t take up as much counter room due to the design.
  • This coffee pot looks very nice and it makes good coffee.
  • It takes less space on cabinet.
  • The lowest it goes is 180 F and the highest is 212 F.
  • It brews quickly, and a coffee pot lip that doesn’t drip all over the place when you pour.
Cons
  • There is a slight plastic smell at the end of the brewing cycle.

Check Price On Amazon

6. Nespresso Vertuo Evoluo Coffee – Espresso Machine by De’Longhi

Espresso Machine by De'Longhi

If you have an espresso machine, then you already know what good espresso can taste like, and this machine offers to make espressos simple without needed to tamper the grounds and the other work. You put the capsule in, add water if your reservoir is empty, press a button, and when you open the lid again, it even deposits your used capsule to the side disposal compartment. It is one very easy and beautiful coffee and espresso machine

The Evoluo premium machine also features an extra-large water tank and capsule container and chromed details. It will do different size cups. Keep in mind the more water the weaker coffee. To program it’s easy, simply put your cup that you want to fill under the spout. You can adjust the strength of your coffee each time again holding the button on top to the desired level.

The milk foamer is easy to use and clean. Just pour in your cold cream, put the lid on, press the button, and in a minute you have your foamed milk. This coffee and milk foamer set is well made quality and just beautiful on your countertop.

It does not come with a general-purpose pod to fill up with your own coffee. However, there is a workaround. The top of each pod is sealed with foil; it’s airtight. Furthermore, the bar code under each pod tells the machine how to best brew the coffee.
Pros
  • A nice coffee variety pack that comes with the machine.
  • Perfect Temperatures.
  • Perfect thick coffees with a thick ‘head’.
  • It makes a really rich foam for the espressos.
  • There are pods that make full to go cups.
Cons
  • The machine makes some noise when brewing.

Check Price On Amazon

7. Keurig K-Elite Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker

Keurig K-Elite Single Serve

The K-Elite coffee maker has the ability to brew coffee, tea, and hot cocoa, it does not brew espresso. There are a number of espresso-roast blends available in K-Cup pods that resemble the flavor and roast of a classic espresso beverage. This Coffee Makers do not dispense cold beverages however, the K-Elite coffee maker makes brewing over ice easy. 

The ice coffee function is a good if you like iced coffee. The Iced button on K-Elite coffee maker makes it easy by pre-selecting the perfect settings so you can enjoy a full-flavored, delicious beverage when brewing over ice.

The machine is easy to figure out how to use and there are clear directions. The filter is easy to set to and install. You can make different sizes: 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12oz cups of coffee. It makes a cup of coffee in less than a minute from turning it on to brew time. You can set it to different temperatures.

The K-Elite coffee maker is designed for home use only and should not be plumbed into a direct water line. The hot water will dispense out of the same nozzle as your coffee. If you are brewing hot water to steep a cup of tea, we would suggest running a cleansing brew first.

We recommend using bottled or filtered water in your Keurig coffee maker. Coffee and tea are over 98% water so quality drinking water is necessary for a good coffee, tea or iced beverage. We do not suggest softened water because sodium ions in softened water form a gelatinous mass around the coffee grounds and tea leaves, slowing down the extraction process and causing over-extraction. This can also clog your coffee maker.
Pros
  • It looks and feels well-built even though its incredibly light.
  • Accepts all k cups as well as refillable ones.
  • It will last a long time.
  • The controls are easier to use.
  • Looks better, and makes slightly better coffee.
Cons
  • There is not an automatic water feed option at this time.
  • It can’t brew a pot.

Check Price On Amazon

8. Nespresso VertuoPlus Deluxe Coffee and Espresso Machine

Deluxe Espresso Machine

VertuoPlus coffee makers use a patented extraction technology developed by Nespresso known as Centrifusion. Centrifusion technology spins up to 7,000 rotations per minute, blending ground coffee with water and producing the perfect in-cup result for each blend.

It’s very easy to set up and you’ll be enjoying your first cup in no time. The included samples are nice to try. Some are pretty good. I apparently don’t like Espresso in the slightest, but the coffee was largely delicious.

In terms of the pods, it definitely has a couple factors that make it a win over the Keurig. First. When you open the lid it automatically ejects the spent pod into a waste bin at the rear of the machine. No digging out someone else’s used pod before inserting your own. Second Nespresso will send you recycling bags for free that include prepaid shipping labels so you can send all the pods back to them for recycling at no cost to you. 

The chrome cup holder is adjustable heights! Great feature, can take it up high for expresso or all the way down for larger coffee. Also, they sell larger capsules specifically for making larger drinks (14 oz vs 8oz) as well. However, they only have a couple of flavor choices for these larger sizes.
Pros
  • Very quiet. Much better than the large one!
  • Makes excellent longer coffees.
  • The original Nespresso is best for shorter coffees.
  • Simple design and easy to use.
  • It comes with many choices of espresso coffee.
Cons
  • The milk frother is not included.

Check Price On Amazon

9. Nespresso Vertuo Evoluo Coffee – Espresso Machine by De’Longhi

Nespresso Vertuo Evoluo Coffee Machine

The Vertuo Evoluo has a motorized head and moveable 60 oz. water tank. The machine has a fast heat up time of only 20-25 seconds and has an automatic shut off after nine minutes. When you purchase the product, you will get a recycling bag. Once the bag is full you send it back. Pretty easy. It comes with a box of 12 different flavors. The coffee maker is high quality. You can make your own high-quality coffees like Americano’s or macchiatos and so on. Even just the coffee itself is so much better than pot of coffee. 

They have two kinds of pods you can buy that are specifically for iced coffees; each pod produces one shot of espresso and then is meant to be added to ice, water, and/or milk, but they’re only offered during the summer. It makes 5 different sizes and strengths of coffee. You can purchase capsules that make 1.35, 2.7, 5, 8 or 14 oz. You can also set the machine to a custom size. Whichever is preferable.

If you like rich coffees with unique flavors this and the Nespresso coffees are a great choice. You can use the coffee and the espresso types in this machine and that is it. Coffee is about 7 ounces and the espresso is about 3 ounces.
Pros
  • It makes great espresso and decaf espresso, for 85 cents a shot.
  • The milk frother is a great edition.
  • The machine itself is well heavy and substantial metal.
  • It allows you to stop the cycle early for stronger coffee.
  • One press of the button and you are good to go.
Cons
  • The temperature of the coffee is around 175 degrees.
  • The bulbs are expensive.

Check Price On Amazon

10. Ninja CF091 Coffee Makers with 50 oz, Silver

Ninja CF091

The next-generation Ninja Coffee Bar is more than a coffeemaker. It’s a coffee system – complete with a variety of brew types and sizes, a built-in frother, and tons of delicious coffee recipes you can create and enjoy at home. The unit comes with a permanent mesh filter. However, if you use “drip grind” coffee off the shelf, small pieces will fall through that filter into your carafe or cup. Adding a paper filter prevents that.

It’s easy to clean outside and has a clean cycle. Use solution and hit the button when it beeps after an hour, refill with water to flush out the system. Just beware that the sensor is defective and that they no longer will replace for sensor issues.

It’s does an ok job of “frothing” milk with the auto-frother on the side that stays hidden until you need it. Overall, a fun way to begin to experience the world of cappuccinos and lattes to see if you’d ever want to go to the next level of actually getting a stand-alone espresso machine

There is a beep that occurs if it’s out of the water and it brews a little loud when making expresso but its short-lived. Nothing louder than a microwave.
Pros
  • Easily add water to the coffee maker.
  • Reusable metal filter works great.
  • The stay warm feature of the heating element under the full carafe can be turned on and off.
  • The “espresso” “shot” actually tastes petty good.
  • Has a nicely spread out shower head to hit.
Cons
  • The frother does not warm the milk.

Check Price On Amazon

Bonus Review:

Hamilton Beach (49976) FlexBrew Coffee Maker

Hamilton Beach coffee makers are thoughtfully designed to make your life easier. This 2-Way Brewer comes with an adjustable drip tray, and can fit a mug up to 7 inches tall for the single-serve side. There are 2 water reservoirs, one for the single cup side (you pour one coffee cup of water at a time with each serving). The other reservoir for the carafe side holds 12 cups. 

There are many, many positives to this machine: the coffee maker side produces hot, fresh coffee that stays hot in the carafe for HOURS. If you’re feeling really fancy, pre-heat it with some hot water to “prime” it just before brewing. That way, you can take the carafe with you into the living room and you and a guest can enjoy some fine coffee while partaking of pleasant conversation in overstuffed chairs–just like at those expensive boutique coffee houses.

The Hamilton Beach flex brew 2-way best Coffee maker has the option to please fans of all types of coffees and quantities, making it the perfect gift for a home with multiple Coffee drinkers.
Pros
  • One coffee maker instead of 2.
  • Uses K-cups or use the separate filter for your own.
  • Less expensive than the Keurig.
  • It’s larger than your average coffee pot.
  • Easy to use controls.
Cons
  • No setting for water temperature.           
  • Separate water reservoirs for carafe and single cup brew.

Check Price On Amazon

Buyer’s Guide

To prepare a good coffee even at home you have a wide range of models available, most of them offered by the best brands of household appliances or even by companies specialized only in the production of coffee makers.

With our guide, we want to take stock of the features you need to look for in a coffee maker before investing your budget, and then propose our personal ranking of the most valid models on the market.

Classic or electric

Even here the purists will have to say about the option of choosing an electric coffee maker, but we think it all depends on the use to which you want it.

In fact, electricity-powered models come with features that make life a lot easier, especially if you’re in a hurry in the morning and don’t have the time to stand behind the coffee maker.

Compare prices and try to understand what features you’re interested in. Among the most appreciated are the timer to operate the coffee maker at a specific time, to experience the luxury of being awakened by the aroma of coffee.

Moreover, these machines usually go out by themselves once the liquid has come out, and some have the possibility of keeping it warm for a few minutes so as to always drink it at the right temperature.

If you are not a black coffee fan, know that there are models that can make a creamy cappuccino or excellent barley coffee without clogging the filter.

The materials and their characteristics

Traditionally, coffee makers are made of aluminum alloy, appreciated for their lightness and for their ability to quickly rise in temperature.

They need constant maintenance, especially regarding the formation of limestone, and you have to be careful not to dent them.

A steel model could be a better choice, because it does not alter the taste of coffee and is resistant in case of bumps or falls. The disadvantages are that it takes longer to heat up and usually the price is higher.

There are coffee pots on the market with the ceramic jug, which has the advantage of slightly lowering the temperature of the coffee as it exits and consequently prevents it from burning.

The coffee pots with glass container are very pleasant from the aesthetic point of view and allow you to control the coffee spillage.

Keep the coffee maker clean and release sour coffee and allergies

Coffee MakerOne of the most common mistakes you can get on the coffee is that it tastes sour. This is usually due to the fact that the coffee maker, and especially the filter funnel, has not been cleaned properly. The coffee may also have tasted foodstuffs with which the coffee beans have been stored.

Cleaning your coffee maker, filter funnel and coffee pot is very important, and not just because of the taste. If you leave the filter with the coffee grounds or leave some coffee in the bottom of the jug, you will create a warm and moist breeding ground for mushroom and mold spores.

If you just drink a jug of coffee every day or use the coffee maker less often, you risk getting mold in the funnel and jug. Therefore, you should always discard the used coffee filter as soon as the coffee is ready. At the same time, it is important to clean and dry both water containers, funnel and jug after each brewing when the finished coffee is poured into a thermos.

If you do not clean these parts before brewing the next batch of coffee you risk getting into the mold spores and the coffee maker also spread mold spores around which remain in the air at your home. This increases the risk that you will develop allergies and in worst-case asthma.

If there are already mold spores, from other damp places in the home, in your indoor climate, the dirty coffee maker can drive the level of mold spores well above the limit values. Keep your coffee maker clean and be sure to whisk well at home to minimize the health risks associated with the coffee maker.

Leave a Comment