10 Best Ice Cream Maker Reviews & Buyer’s Guide 2020

The ice cream maker is a very practical household appliance allowing you to make your own ice creams and above all to be able to control the origin of the ingredients. As you probably know, far too many industrial ice creams are made from chemical colors or artificial flavors. These same ice creams are often packaged in non-recyclable plastic containers and this is quite harmful for the environment.

Buying an ice cream maker is therefore an eco-responsible and sustainable purchase. And it is also very economical because it is still much cheaper per kilo than industrial ice cream makes you pay for marketing, transport and all the packaging that goes with it.

But it is true that there are many models of ice cream makers on the market and it is often difficult to make a choice. As a home chef, I have had the opportunity to try many different ice cream makers. So I decided to take advantage of this professional experience to help you choose your future ice cream maker by offering you a complete buying guide and a comparative table.

Different Type of Ice Cream Maker

First of all, it is important to differentiate the types of devices that can allow you to make ice cream:

The ice-cream maker with cold accumulator: this is a machine that allows you to brew the preparation for ice cream but whose tank must be placed in the freezer beforehand for several hours. The main advantage of this system is the cheaper price than ice turbines.

The ice turbine (or independent / compressor ice-cream maker): this is a more powerful device that generates cold independently without having to use your freezer during manufacturing. This machine will take care of brewing and cooling simultaneously to save you time. The preparation of your ice creams will be faster but the purchase cost a little higher than an ice cream maker with a cold accumulator.

You will therefore have to choose between these two types of ice cream makers, the choice will be made according to your needs but especially your budget. To know that the ice turbine is more efficient and will allow you to make your ice cream faster and without having to place a vat for many hours in the freezer.

The best ice cream makers of 2020

During the hottest months of the year, the idea of ​​eating a nice ice cream is even more tempting but, if made with genuine ingredients and using a quality ice cream maker, you can prepare and enjoy it every day, even in winter. Below we have compared the best professional ice cream machines to help you choose the one that meets your needs.

Ice Cream MakerCapacityFrozen Time 
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker [Our Top Pick]2.0-quart25 Min Check Price
Yogurt-Ice Cream Maker [Editor's Choice]1.5-quart20 Min Check Price
Ice Cream and Gelato Maker1.5-quart10 Min Check Price
Klarstein Ice Cream Maker4.0-quart10 Min Check Price
Aicok Ice Cream Maker1.6-quart15 Min Check Price
Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker [Beautiful Design]4.0-quart25 Min Check Price
BIMONK Ice Cream Maker1.5-quart20 Min Check Price
Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker4.0-quart30 Min Check Price
Cool Creations Ice Cream Maker2.0-quart20 Min Check Price
Costway Ice Cream Maker1.6-quart15 Min Check Price

1. Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-30R

Check Price on Amazon

This Magimix model embodies perfection in terms of the ice machine. The tanks do not need to be pre-cooled in the freezer, as the cooling system is already integrated. It makes delicious, smooth and creamy soft serve in about 20 minutes. The machine itself is incredibly easy to use and keep clean.

It is a highly durable strong aluminum. It has some weight due to it’s double-sided form. It’s a heavier liquid that has a slooshing sound when not frozen. You can also make gelato, sorbet, and slushes in less amount of time. It can get a little loud as the ice cream thickens, but I think that’s the same with most machines.

The machine sits on the counter. A freezer bowl is inserted in the machine. It is best to freeze the bowl for 24 hours prior to using it. The machine is slightly larger than a drip coffee maker. The bowl that contains the ice cream is removable and stores in the freezer when not in use.

The paddle is plastic and simply sits in the bowl and the lid helps hold it in place. Bowl has a sort of gear indentation to the bottom which fits the machine so that it spins. Only a large mixing blade, the plastic see-thru cover and the 2-quart container to clean. Hot water cleans everything quickly or you can put parts in a dishwasher.

It doesn’t have a built-in Compressor, a model that does will cost 5-10x the price. Of course, it isn’t going to make rock-hard ice cream right out of the freezer bowl. It isn’t designed to.
Why I Like It
  • It is easy to use and fun too
  • You add all the ingredients
  • It makes the ice cream within 25 minutes
  • Limited 3-year warranty
  • The parts are easy to clean
Why I Don't Like It
  • It is little bit loud but ok
  • Much ice forming while making the ice cream

2. Cuisinart ICE-21 Ice Cream Maker

Yogurt-Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Cuisinart is the leading company making great quality ice cream maker. The Cuisinart ICE-21 offered at an affordable price, makes delicious sorbets, but also ice cream and many desserts. The bowl offers a large capacity since it can make, with each preparation, up to 1.5 L of ice. The funnel for pouring the ingredients is wide.

The fully automatic Cuisinart Frozen Yoghurt Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker lets you turn ingredients into a delicious and healthy frozen treat with no fuss and no mess. It does not use ice. It also makes chocolate very well, as with all ice cream they come out like soft serve. If you want hard freeze for a couple of hours.

This is a really simple to operate the machine. It has only one button which you can see in the middle of the device in the product picture. That is an on/off switch and that’s it. This is a great little ice cream maker. It does small batches so you can experiment with flavors much more easily than with a large old-fashioned ice cream maker.

When substituting a lower fat milk product you can improve the texture by using Knox unflavored gelatin. There are wonderful recipes on the Splenda site as well. Think of this product as a way to experiment and have fun. You can use any ice cream or sherbet recipe you like best. It does them all.

The bowl needs to be upright and in the back of the freezer for best results-it does take up a good bit of space. It takes up about the same amount of space as a store bought ice-cream carton, so keep this in mind before purchasing.
Why I Like It
  • Large capacity makes up to 1-1/2-quarts
  • The instruction is clear and concise
  • Recipes are included
  • Easy lock transparent lid with large spout
  • The machine appears to be solidly built
Why I Don't Like It
  • This bowl requires low freezer temperature
  • The bowl is not dishwasher safe

3. Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream Maker

Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Check Price on Amazon

The easy to use, fully automatic Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream and Gelato Maker features a commercial-style compressor so you can make batch after batch without waiting. Its two unique mixing paddles and a 60-minute countdown timer work to ensure your homemade gelato, ice cream or sorbet has the perfect consistency.

This ice cream maker comes with separate paddle designs: one for ice cream and another for gelato. The recipe book involves some ingredient cooking before placing in the device, whereas for ice cream you just mix the stuff, refrigerate it for an hour and pour it in and press start.

The inside where the bucket sits is aluminum. Its fairly heavy and durable, minimal noise. When you on this unit, the power button is illuminated by a red LED light. You can set the countdown timer from 10 minutes to 60 minutes. The quantity of liquid however is too much.

This machine will make your ice cream basically soft serve. From that point, spoon ice cream into another container and freeze. It will be firm in about an hour. It doesn’t make it rock hard such as the ice cream you buy in the stores, but it is definitely the consistency such that you can scoop it and it will hold the shape.

The canister is anodized aluminum. Never use any metal utensils. Always use a rubber spoon or spatula. It takes about 30 minutes per batch, then remove batch, followed by a 10-minute cool-off period, then clean and refill. So you would need about 50 minutes per batch.
Why I Like It
  • Touchpad Control Panel
  • It freezes in about 30 minutes
  • Mixing bowl with lift-out handle
  • It’s very easy to use
  • Fully automatic with a commercial quality compressor
Why I Don't Like It
  • The machine is a little large
  • It’s not easy to clean

4. Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream Maker

Klarstein

Check Price on Amazon

The Dolce Bacio is a true turbo ice cream machine that solidifies the ingredients you select in the machine’s thermal mixer, creating up to 67 fl oz of delicious and fresh creamy ice cream within one hour. The bowl is completely removable. It comes with a nice handler in order to pull it out very easily.

The Dolce Bacio ice cream maker is ideal for making ice cream for the whole family since it can hold up to 4 quarts, enough for about 10 people. It also has a cold keeping function which switches on automatically once the mixing is finished, and takes around 10 minutes before the machine goes into standby mode.

The ice cream maker is easy to operate with all settings adjustable via the intuitive control panel and the digital display. After mixing the machine intuitively switches to a one-hour cooling mode. This item also comes with an instruction manual. You can use any recipe you wish, add it to the container and select turn it on. You can set the timer in 10-minute increments between 10–60 minutes.

The container is made of aluminum however it is very safe to use since it has a dense coated layer to prevent toxicity or taste changes. The bowl inside is metal, a thick one, not a flimsy one but not sure if it is stainless steel. The lids and mixing parts are made from molded plastic and the shell is also made of metal. The mixing attachment is a sturdy plastic.

This machine can make ice cream from almond milk. But you need to understand what makes ice cream good. Non-fat makes it icy…not sure how almond milk will freeze. Overall this machine is great for home use as well as commercial.
Why I Like It
  • It is extremely quiet and easy to operate/clean
  • It has a sleek brushed satin stainless steel housing
  • Great for large family
  • The large LCD display is backlit and easy to read
  • Made from strong materials
Why I Don't Like It
  • Little bit expensive

5. Aicok BL1500C Ice Cream Maker

Aicok Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

If you like the idea of delicious ice cream at the touch of a button, then the Aicok ice cream maker is the best choice for you. It’s six ice cream maker recipes to get you started, these include vanilla ice cream, strawberry ice cream, raspberry frozen yogurt, chocolate mint ice cream, banana ice cream, and lemon sorbet.

This machine allows you to control exactly what goes into your dessert. It is important for those who want to avoid additives, or are watching their calorie intake. The inner bowl is Stainless steel, this ice cream maker is powerful and useful. If you plan to offer a gift for 6 years old child, I think it is OK. You can help your child learning more skills and get lots of fun!

AICOK ice cream machine comes with a recipe book that provides useful hints and tips. You can also create or use ice cream recipes of your own. Its detachable mixing arm and freezer bowl are easy to remove for cleaning. When it’s done, you’ll hear the motor struggle a bit more because of the thickness of the ice cream.

The machine contains two major parts, paddle and a drum, aka the freezer bowl. The night before you intend to make ice cream (or earlier) park your clean freezer bowl in the coldest part of your freezer overnight. This is essential that the bowl is frozen through with no sloshing sound.

Pre-freezing the inner bowl takes around 12 hours, so I highly recommend you simply pop it in the freezer the night before. Reminder: The mixing bowl must be completely frozen. You can know this through shaking the container, if cannot hear the liquid sound, then already freeze completely.
Why I Like It
  • This ice cream maker is great for the price
  • Fast homemade ice cream
  • Fantastic health-benefits
  • Recipes suggestions & easy cleaning
  • Large ingredient funnel
Why I Don't Like It
  • Size is little bit small
  • The instruction isn’t great

6. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE Electric Ice Cream Maker

Aicok Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Nostalgia ice cream maker features a locking motor mount, easy-to-clean plastic bucket, and 4-quart aluminum canister. This capacity is also higher than the market average, most competing machines are content with 1.5 liter. It’s come out of the ice cream maker with the consistency of ice.

Its transparent cover has an opening for adding additional ingredients during preparation. At the top of this cover, you can see an electronic screen on which the on/off button is located, and which allows you to monitor the progress of the preparation.

The blue bucket is not, but the mixer is dishwasher safe. The blue bucket only contains ice and salt, so it’s very simple to clean. It makes just short of a gallon of ice cream. You can chill it in the freezer before you start making the ice-cream, and after you make the ice-cream you can store it in the freezer.

This machine also promises a high quality ice cream in 25 minutes, which is much shorter than what the competition offers. This method of ice cream making isn’t the easiest to do but if you can’t afford a hundreds-of-dollars-machine it is well worth the few bucks to put out.

In addition to the instructions, it comes with an ice cream scoop to facilitate the preparation of your frozen desserts. The instructions state that once you’ve mixed your ingredients, you should place the metal bowl into your freezer until it is cold to the touch.
Why I Like It
  • This is so quick and easy to use
  • The size is perfect
  • Ice cream freezes plenty hard
  • Food quality, durable, easy to set up
  • Easy to clean and store
Why I Don't Like It
  • The motor is pretty loud when spinning
  • Large size so not good choice for a small family

7. BIMONK Detachable Frozen Bowl Ice Cream Maker

Detachable Frozen Bowl

Check Price on Amazon

BIMONK 1.5 Quart home-made ice cream maker not only provides an opportunity for your treating families and friends, but also allows you to control the amount of sugar and fat for organic foods without flavors sacrificed. It has a functional handle for easy and comfortable gripping.

It’s made in China, but it is very good quality and works well. Recipes are metric, but can easily be converted. Compared to other ice cream makers out there that cost as much or are a lot higher, this maker performs pretty well for the price and is a small buy for the family to increase in house activities.

Large sprout for easy adding ingredients such as dark chocolate chips, nuts and other stuffs you want. The outside is plastic the inside is stainless steel with something liquid in between to freeze. The freeze bowl is made from out TP and inner aluminum.

Delectable dairy-free ice cream is also made with this product, Fiber-rich fruits and vegetables can be good alternatives, such as pumpkin puree, strawberry, because the fibrous materials in the fruits can help to add a little extra thickness to the batter, just remember to freeze them first.

One of the downsides about the product is the large cylinder bucket you need to freeze before first use. The cylinder helps make the ice cream but since it’s rather larger, you will need to clear out some space in the freezer to let it freeze for about 8 hours.
Why I Like It
  • 1.5 quarts of ice cream in one batch
  • One-knob for automatic on/off
  • Super easy and fun to use
  • Irregular paddle for sufficient scraping and churning
  • Effortless cleaning
Why I Don't Like It
  • The recipes in the instruction booklet are simple

8. Nostalgia Electric Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia Electric Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

With a real wood exterior that’s reminiscent of the old fashioned hand-crank ice cream makers. This ice cream maker features plenty of modern convenience and a plastic interior makes cleaning up a breeze.

The material which the tube of the freezer is made of is wood. Which is good for insulation for the metal can. And also help in speed up the freezing process of the ingredient inside the rotating metal container of the ice-cream freezer, and the motor housing is made of hard plastic, which could last over ten years easily of usage.

It is also good for rust prevention, yet it makes ice-cream within 20 to 30 minutes. The bucket is stylish enough that when it is not in use you can use it as a counter top decoration that holds various snacks for our kids. Very easy clean up. No hassles, small parts, or hard to clean areas.

You can use all-natural ingredients. It comes with recipes or you can find them online. You make the ice cream base and at first the base is a liquid. The machine freezes it and makes it the consistency of soft-serve ice cream. This ice cream maker doesn’t come with salt. It is a good ice cream maker though.

When using the proper amount of ice and salt the cream is ready to serve in 35 to 45 minute,(it take practice to learn the proper amount of ice and salt) it doesn’t get as hard as store ice cream unless you put it in the freezer.
Why I Like It
  • Comes with complete instructions and recipe book
  • The Electric motor locks into place
  • Very easy clean up
  • The bucket is seamless
  • Very reasonable price
Why I Don't Like It
  • Old design
  • A little bit noisy

9. Cuisinart ICE-60W Cool Creations Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-60W Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Cuisinart ICE-60W ice cream maker has all your frozen delights covered – ice cream, gelato, frozen yoghurt, and sorbet. Making any family favorite couldn’t be simpler thanks to the one-button operation for ice cream, gelato, and sorbet and auto shutoff to make entertaining easy.

the Cuisinart ICE-60W ice cream maker is equipped with a cold accumulator bowl with a capacity of 2 liters which has a double wall containing coolant. This is a very high-quality machine that is double-walled with some sort of liquid that sloshes around when the bowl is not frozen.

This Cuisinart ice cream maker has a square shape and a style that appeals to its simplicity. Its sleek design is also highlighted by its white plastic color. Its transparent cover is a real plus in that it allows monitoring the progress of the preparation.

The outside is of a thick plastic that surrounds a double-walled sturdy aluminum core that contains the freezing liquid. This should make a delicious “Samoa” type of ice cream. Just make the ice cream, scoop some in a bowl, and then add all the extras into your bowl.

The timer is a nice addition on the higher-end model, but probably not worth the extra cost. If you wait 15-20 min while it’s doing its magic, you will hear the beeps and know when to stop it. Definitely freeze the inner container before using, and even then, it’s better if you put the product in the freezer after making it but before eating it.
Why I Like It
  • 2-quart popular capacity
  • Improved paddle with faster processing time
  • Control panel with 3 settings with multiple speeds
  • Ingredient spout with an integrated measuring cup
  • Modern and beautiful design
Why I Don't Like It
  • It is not dishwasher safe
  • Little bit expensive

10. Costway 23818US-GN-CYPE Ice Cream Maker

Costway Ice Cream Maker

Check Price on Amazon

Last but not least, this is a brand new macarons color series ice cream machine which allows you to use your imagination and creativity to make your own ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, etc. perfectly. Its large chute on the cover enables you to add ingredients such as fruits, chocolate, nuts, candies, etc. freely during mixing.

1.6-quart aluminum freezing bowl has large enough capacity to accommodate ice cream for the whole family. Fun and creative way to spend time with your family with a tasty reward. The intelligent mixing paddle is stirred at an ideal speed to ensure the mixture is evenly mixed, and helping you make smoother and delicious frozen desserts in 15 to 20 minutes.

This Costway ice cream machine comes with a recipe book that offers useful tips for you. Its anti-skid colloidal particles at the bottom make the machine difficult to dump. After setting the time, the ice cream maker will automatically start to stir, the remaining time is indicated on the LCD screen. You can simply choose a running time from 20 minutes to 40 minutes.

This ice cream maker has an integrated refrigeration system to cool the preparations immediately when in use. No more trouble placing the tank in the freezer several hours in advance. When making ice cream, however, avoid pouring hot ingredients directly.
Why I Like It
  • Intelligently mixing paddle
  • Fully automatic & simple operation
  • A great choice for small family
  • Detachable parts for easy cleaning
  • Noise is as low as 65 db
Why I Don't Like It
  • This unit has no cons

How to Choose Best Ice Cream Maker

You just have to sacrifice a minute of your time to get correct information – perhaps reading our guide to choose the best ice cream maker – to spare yourself all the rage for a purchase that does not meet our needs and our expectations. Most important factors for choosing an ice cream maker given below:

Price and consumption

To buy a model equipped with a compressor requires a decidedly higher initial outlay (often much higher than 100 dollars for a quality model). The consumption of these devices is also high so that they have to be taken into account in the calculation of the appliances that can be used simultaneously. Moreover, the possibility of obtaining ice cream in 30-60 minutes without any previous preparation is an important advantage.

The accumulation models have a very low cost (typically under 100 dollars, even a lot) and their engine consumes very little (remember that they use the normal freezer for cooling) and will have virtually no impact on the electricity bill. However, they require advance planning and can be used in practice only once a day.

Capacity and Speed

Two other very important aspects to consider are capacity and speed. Do you have a large group of children who can’t wait to taste their daily ice cream? Based on this question, you will be able to choose the model that suits your needs. The capacity of the ice cream makers can vary a lot and some models allow you to get more than 2 kg of ice cream in a single session.

If you have a large family and a lover of ice cream, you could also consider the speed factor. Being able to redo a new load of ice cream within an hour could “save your life” on more than one occasion.

From this point of view, self-cooling machines can only be at the top of the rankings.

Preparation time

In this case, the preparation times do not differ much from those of the accumulation ice cream makers, although it is more difficult to find ice cream makers that fall below 20 minutes. What really makes the difference, however, is the ability to set the desired time thanks to the appropriate commands and therefore to be able to adjust the consistency of the ice cream to our liking.

Some machines also provide the possibility to choose between a manual and an automatic function: the first allows us to adjust the time according to the ingredients and our tastes and needs, with the second one instead the rotation of the blade stops once the ice cream has reached a certain consistency.

Cold maintenance functions

In addition to time-keeping, many machines also include a cold-hold function, which allows ice cream to be kept out of the fridge for a long time. Clearly, storage machines can keep ice cream out of the fridge without melting a certain amount of time, but this can be very variable depending on the outside temperature. The cold maintenance function has a defined period of time, and can last even for a maximum period of 2 hours.

Ease of use

An ice cream maker is such a practical device that you may use it frequently, especially during the summer. So choose a practical and intuitive machine to use. The presence of an LCD screen is appreciable and you can choose a device that shuts off automatically, has a keep cold function, a timer, two tanks and a pause mode or a removable cover for add ingredients during the process.

The noise level

It is also important to pay particular attention to the noise emitted by the device in operation. If you plan to use the ice cream maker in an open room or near a living room, it is best to go on a quieter model. By this I mean a model that emits no more than 65 or 70 dB in operation. We all like ice cream, but less the noise from these devices.

How to clean your ice machine?

It is very easy to maintain an ice cream maker since there are not many different items to clean.

Cleaning the tank: the tank can be removable, if this is the case it will facilitate cleaning considerably. You can remove it and clean it in a sink. But more often these tanks can be washed in the dishwasher.

If the tank is integrated into the appliance, cleaning should be carried out using a sponge, taking care to unplug the appliance beforehand.

If you use a cold storage device, it should not be washed with hot water. Using hot water can damage the insulated tank lining and significantly affect the quality of your future ice cream. This tank is therefore washed in cold water after waiting for it to return to room temperature.

Body cleaning: for cleaning the body of the appliance, it will also be very simple and even more so if your ice cream maker has a stainless steel body. You can use a soft cloth and a little soap or washing-up liquid to clean the walls. Be careful, you will turn off the power before unplugging it to avoid any risk if a little water leaks out. Of course no dishwasher because it is an electrical appliance.

Frequently Questions Answered

Ice cream maker or cold accumulator, which type of ice cream maker to choose?

Ice-cream maker type ice cream makers are more practical than cold accumulators, in the sense that there is no need to plan to put the bowl in the freezer 12 hours in advance for a tasting. However, their prices remain very high (100 dollars minimum) and they take up much more space.

How long does it take to make ice cream with an ice cream maker?

Once the cooling phase of the appliance has passed (around 12 hours in a freezer for ice cream makers of the cold accumulator type), the production of ice cream is very rapid. You just have to put the ingredients you want and mix everything: a total of about thirty minutes maximum is enough.

What capacity to choose for your ice cream maker?

The capacity of the ice cream maker will vary depending on the use you make of it. The “classic” capacity of the ice cream makers is 1 L. This is enough to make sorbets or ice creams for 2 to 3 people. If your needs are higher, it is advisable to choose an ice cream maker with a larger capacity.

Leave a Comment