10 Best Ice Cube Trays Reviews & Buyer’s Guide in 2020

Ice Cube Trays Review

Whether you’re making a craft cocktail or just sipping lemonade on the porch, ice in the glass is a must. If you’re looking for an easy way to amplify your drinks, why not buy some fun ice cube trays. It seems like an unnecessary gadget, but there are countless advantages worth buying for it.

The ice cube trays on the market allow you to indulge yourself because in addition to the classic cube shape. But to choose the right one it is important to evaluate some aspects, such as durability, material, size, shape according to your needs.

Best Ice Cube Trays in 2020

Below we have selected the best ice cube trays on the market, made with different materials and each with peculiar characteristics and more or less advantageous prices, in order to meet the needs of a large clientele. Whatever your preferences, in this ranking you will certainly find the right tray for you!

The main Reviews are updated regularly in a professional manner. Now check the comparison table of top 10 best ice cube trays in 2020.

Ice Cube TraysTotal TraysCube Size 
Vremi Silicone Ice Cube Trays [Top Ranking]2 Pcs1.3-inch Check Price
Korlon 3 Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays [Editor's Choice]3 Pcs1.3-inch Check Price
glacio Ice Cube Trays Silicone2 Pcs1.3-inch Check Price
Samuelworld Ice Cube Tray [For Whiskey and Cocktails]2 Pcs2.0-inch Check Price
Vremi Large Silicone Ice Cube Trays2 Pcs1.75-inch Check Price
Silicone Flexible Ice Cube Trays3 Pcs1.3-inch Check Price
Ice Mold Cube Trays Silicone DaCool2 Pcs1.0-inch Check Price
CATWALK Silicone Ice Cube Trays4 Pcs1.5-inch Check Price
Ice Cube Trays with Lid2 Pcs1.1-inch Check Price
Souper Cubes Large Freezing Tray1 Pcs4.25-inch Check Price

1. Vremi Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lids – Our Top Pick

Vremi Silicone Ice Cube Trays

Check Price on Amazon

The Vremi Straight Chillin’ Ice Cube Trays are made for the people who need large size of ice. This ice tray is made of durable rubber. The produces ice cubes are perfect and easy to get out. You can just press on the rubber bottom and the cubes come out. The tray is silicone but the lid is a harder plastic-like material.

It comes with details and care. This set includes 1 blue tray and 1 red tray. 8 large ice cubes per tray, and 16 ice cubes total. Each cube measures 1.75 square inches on all sides. They are both flexible and extremely robust, you can push from the bottom of the trays to push the cubes out.

You can fill the ice cube molds with leftover brew for some top-notch iced coffee. They’re great for freezing homemade kid food, chicken or vegetable stock, and for portioning out small treats like chocolates, peanut butter cups, popsicles, or anything you want to be divided into mini yet mighty portions.

Keep in mind that while the lids are useful for stacking the trays, they do not keep an airtight seal on the trays. This won’t matter if you’re using the trays for water/ice, but if using for food, you won’t be able to store frozen food for a long period of time.
Why I Like It
  • Flexible ice cube trays for freezer
  • Heavy-duty pop release silicone
  • Multi-purpose for dorm or RV
  • Stackable with no-spill lids
  • Dishwasher safe
Why I Don't Like It
  • The silicon is a little tougher than others
  • The lids are not an airtight seal

2. Korlon Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – Editor’s  choice

Korlon 3 Pack

Check Price on Amazon

This ice cube tray is made of flexible silicone which makes it easy to pop the cubes out by pressing on the underside. Korlon ice cube trays covered with PP lids, keep your ice clean and free from freezer odors, easy to stack and save room in freezer, prevent leaking, and help you make perfect shaped cubes.

It has 21 cube compartments each ice tray, which is separated, single cube dimensions 1.3 inches. The actual cubes are a bit small but perfectly sized for all beverages. Korlon ice cube trays are made of premium food-grade silicone, you can assure that your ice tray and lid will not crack in the future.

I like especially the size and design, they are easy to fill if you use the lid underneath the silicone tray to fill it with water and the ice cubes come out easily. They’re great for ice cubes and great for truffle molds. Considering the proposed price, this set is quite a bargain.

The cover on these takes care of the taste and allows you to stack the otherwise floppy silicone trays on top of each other without spilling water all over the freezer. The use of silicone also allows withstanding very low or very high temperatures without risk of deformation.

Why I Like It
  • perfect for baking or freezing anything
  • Easy to clean and store
  • Great for multiple uses
  • Very reasonable price
  • Easy to release
Why I Don't Like It
  • Tray cover does not seal perfectly
  • Not great if you use a lot of ice

3. Glacio Mini Size Ice Cube Trays Silicone with Lids 

glacio Ice Cube Trays

Check Price on Amazon

Glacio brings you a set of 2 premium silicone trays that redefines what it means to ‘just make ice’. Glacio ice cube trays silicone design allows for easy push release every time – simply turn your tray around and pop the cube right out. They snap on well enough to move filled trays without spilling water.

These silicone ice cube trays work so much better than plastic ones. They make perfect shaped cubes that don’t break when you remove them from the tray. You simply push them out from the back. The cubes also don’t stick to the silicone. The tray lids are a nice touch too.

This BPA Free ice cube trays measure in at 5 inches wide by 10.3 inches long and each cube measures 1.3-inch wide. 7 rows of 3 cubes in each tray combine for a total of 21 ice cubes in one go. Larger amount in the same space as other trays combines with insulating silicone surface contact to let cubes freeze faster.

The rim is thicker but still silicone, and the lids are clear plastic. Makes it pretty flimsy if you carry it by the long ends when it’s filled with water. The middle sags. They hold up pretty good. Also, it’s better when you put the lids on for that reason and to protect the tops.

Why I Like It
  • Versatile functionality
  • Easy push release silicone design
  • It comes with a stylish white color
  • They are very stable
  • Non-toxic BPA free
Why I Don't Like It
  • When you fill them with water they’re a little flimsy

4. Samuelworld Flexible Silicone Ice Cube Tray – Large Size

Samuelworld

Check Price on Amazon

Samuelworld large ice cube chilling the drink fast but melt slow, it could keep the drink cool without diluting. You won’t need to take your drink in hurry, just take the time to enjoy your drink. It can make 8 big squares under 2 inches at once. And they are pretty flexible.

Regarding the cleaning, Samuelworld ice cube trays are dishwasher safe. It can use to make Ice cream, Ice sucker, juice, jam or even to be a container for any of your needs. You can also use it as a baking tray. Perfect to chill cocktails, whiskey, tequila, vodka or other drinks with less dilution. 

The bottom of the tray features a chamfer which gives the cube a classy, professional look and the smooth walls make for a very clean surface finish. They are quite light, maybe a pound each. When full, obviously they weigh significantly more, but you will go through a lot less ice using these.

With either 6- or 8-cube tray, don’t cut yourself: the cubes freeze with their outer edges higher than the center, at enough of an angle to produce an edge sharp enough to cut the side of your thumb if squeezing the end cubes out from the side; always push out from the bottom to avoid.

Why I Like It
  • Very simple to use 
  • Mufti-function use
  • Cubes last a long time
  • It is lightweight and flexible
  • These trays are very flexible
Why I Don't Like It
  • A little tough to get the cubes out of the mold
  • The lid is hard plastic, and clips to the soft silicone

5. Vremi 2 Pack Large Ice Cube Trays – Best for Baby Food

Vremi Large Ice Cube Trays for Whiskey

Check Price on Amazon

The silicone vremi ice cube and Dr. Tray set is here to cool you down. This 2-pack ice cube maker molds a total of 16 ice cubes that each measure 1. 75 inches. The tray itself is made of silicon rubber and they are slightly shiny inside. If you let them sit on the counter for about 2 min the cubes pop out very easily.

This ice tray is made of durable rubber, but the lid is harder like plastic. The ice cubes are perfect and easy to get out. You can just press on the rubber bottom and the cubes come out. It is also perfect if you have dogs or even if you wanted to make treats for yourself.

Big ice cubes are a must for any liquor drinker that takes anything on the rocks. All you really need is one or two cubes for any standard cup or glass and you’re good to go. The trays are also very light and a good choice for those who like a quality drink.

The lids are not an airtight seal, so you wouldn’t be able to store food for a long period of time. All parts can be cleaned in the top rack of dishwasher. Do not use in microwave or oven for full care instructions and safety warnings, always refer to Vremi product box or manual.
Why I Like It
  • Easy to clean and does not hold odors
  • Stackable with no-spill lids
  • Large cocktail ice cube trays
  • Flexible for liquids and solids
  • Decorative and compact
Why I Don't Like It
  • For a perfect result, you need to hand wash before first use
  • The lids do not lockdown

6. Three-Pack Silicone Easy Release Silicone Ice Cube Trays

3 Packs

Check Price on Amazon

Three packs best quality silicone ice cube trays with lids easy release ice trays set make 45 large ice cube flexible ice cube mold with ice tongs. It is perfect for Coffee & Tea, Wine & Coconut Milk, Lemon & Chocolate. You can also use it for Herbs & Fruit filled ice cubes and Homemade baby food.

The flexibility of silicone and partially separated cubes compartments allow ice to release a breeze and remove ice cubes from flexible silicone trays by pushing up from the bottom. If your budget is cheap, I highly recommend this new design icecube trays.

Although these ice cube trays are brand new, their quality and cheap price appreciate us to includes it in our top 10 list. They are made of 100% food-grade silicone, BPA Free and FDA approved to keep your ice safe for drinking. It looks simple but a complete ice cube tray set. 

Why I Like It
  • Easy to fill and release
  • Perfect size for multiple uses
  • Lightweight design
  • Strong & durable
  • Very cheap price
Why I Don't Like It
  • Lid/covers are useless and don’t stay on whatsoever

7. DaCool Silicone Food Grade 2-Pack Ice Cube Trays

Silicone Ice Cube Mold

Check Price on Amazon

These ice cube trays work great and make really neat shaped ice cubes. They come with two lids so you can cover them when you put them in the freezer. You have to use both hands to hold it and put it in the freezer. The tray also has a little handle area on the side. The ice is very easy to take off with a push from the back. 

Small about the size of a box of grits in length cubes shaped like honeycombs cubes. It also makes a lot more ice cubes than your average ice trays. DaCool Silicone ice cube trays are very comfortable to use, and the water does not spill out at all because of the cover they come with. Perfect for the fridge.

The lids do not snap on to the trays, so it is still possible to dribble water on the way to the freezer. The trays themselves do not leak. The flexible silicone material makes it easy to release ice cubes. Instead of multiple ice cube trays, DaCool offers this unique 74 cube bottom.

Why I Like It
  • Stackable & removable Lid
  • Durable & dishwasher safe
  • Easy release of ice mold trays
  • Able to produce 74 cubes of ice
  • Very easy to clean
Why I Don't Like It
  • Cube size is too short compare others
  • A little difficult to fill

8. Candyman CATWALK Silicone 4-Pack Ice Cube Trays

CATWALK Silicone 4 Pack

Check Price on Amazon

Each tray includes its own lid, so there are two trays and 2 lids. Of course, the lids are truly 100% leak proof in case of tipping when properly attached. The size of each space is 1.18×1.57×1.14 inches, you can figure out how many tablespoons can fit in each space with this size.

They are sturdy and come with covers, but the bottoms of the cubes are silicone. So you can push the cubes out easily without the whole thing being pliable. The lid is designed for stacking and containing the ice cubes when pressing the desired quantity out if you tilt they will leak.

The cubes are great for putting into sports bottles and are a little smaller than the regular ice tray cubes. The lid on the top is more for stacking not to keep freshly filled trays from spilling. It comes with smart design, good size cubes, and very easy to use.

They are not your usual ice cube trays that you struggle to get ice out of as these have rubber bottoms that make it easier to pop out the ice. Don’t fill the tray all the way up to max. Ice will expand as it freezes and will pop the lid off.
Why I Like It
  • Food-Grade materials
  • Multipurpose ice maker
  • Spill-resistant design
  • Ice removal easily
  • Stack easily and neatly in the freezer without sticking
Why I Don't Like It
  • For the first time, the ice is usually tightly attached to the mold

9. Guardians Silicone 2-Set Ice Cube Trays with Lid

Ice Cube Trays with Lid

Check Price on Amazon

Guardians ice trays are 24 cubes for each tray, and each cube is about 1.1” by 1.1”, neither large nor small, fits every glass and cool your beverage to the ideal temperature for a long time. There is a hook for you to place on the wall. Each ice tray comes with a lid so they can be stackable and help to keeps the ice cubes clean. 

The silicone ice cube trays are great for whiskey, Moscow mules, Iced Tea, cool-aid, water, or any other mixed drink. The plastic lid helps keep the food or ice more clean. They are made of food-grade silicone, BPA Free and FDA Approved, healthy to use, flexible and easier to pop out the ice than other plastic ice trays.

These are dishwasher safe and good quality for the price. Particularly the bottom is non-slip. The top does not really snap on tight. The silicone allows water to freeze a little quicker than normal. Dispensing is very easy. It is a great space saver and a good choice for children or parents.

Why I Like It
  • There is a hook for you to place on the wall
  • Great for multiple uses 
  • Perfect size for freezing
  • Soft and durable
  • Reasonable price
Why I Don't Like It
  • Very small cubes in comparison to other ice trays

10. Souper Cubes Extra-Large Silicone Freezing Tray

Extra-Large Ice Cube Tray

Check Price on Amazon

Souper Cubes was designed to make it easy to freeze soup, broth, sauce, and other liquids in measured amounts so that it’s effortless and convenient to enjoy single servings or reuse for recipes. Its eight frozen cubes can fit in a standard gallon-sized freezer bag for longer-term storage in your freezer.

The Souper-Cubes are the perfect size for a bowl of soup. Simply ladle soup into each cube – actually can hold a little better than 1 C measure. I highly recommend the lid so that you can stack on it and the food is covered. The included lids contain a leak-proof seal, keep unwanted odors away.

Food grade silicone from products like this one does not leave a rubbery taste. The bottoms are free of lines or any texture but the sides have lines and text indicating cup and ml levels. They are easy and convenient to use and make it so you can put so much more in the freezer. 

Why I Like It
  • Freeze food in perfect portions
  • Easy to clean & dishwasher safe
  • Sturdy steel-reinforced construction
  • Each well has four fill lines
  • Extra-large cube
Why I Don't Like It
  • The liquid takes a longer time to freeze

Bonus Review:

#Thermi Ice Cube Tray with Easy Release Push Pop Out

Thermi Ice Cube Tray

Check Price on Amazon

This unique design uses silicone cups so you can pop out only the ice sticks you need to use. No more twisting and banging against counter-tops to get ice out. Perfect for water bottles, cans, beer bottles, or insulated stainless steel sports bottles. This thee trays set are BPA-free, and it is a fantastic set at a cheap price.

The whitish translucent part of the ice tray is fairly rigid plastic, and the colorful part is nice squishy silicone, so they’re kind of the best of both worlds. Rigid enough to be stackable, but it’s easy to push the ice sticks out, too. And the ice sticks fit perfectly into water bottles.

The 3 pack consists of 1 midnight blue ice tray, 1 frost blue ice tray, 1 lime green ice tray. And each tray holds approximately 8 fl oz total. If you are planning to use this ice stick ice trays in the oven to make these fire sticks, this can not be done as the plastic will melt!

Why I Like It
  • Perfect choice for any drink
  • Stack your ice trays and save space
  • Easy to pop the ice out
  • Make 30 long ice sticks
  • Great for water bottle
Why I Don't Like It
  • A bit flimsy when fully filled
  • Stick piece ice

Buyer’s Guide

Ice cube tray is a simple kitchen tool and it is essential. But not all ice cube trays work the same. When shopping for an ice cube tray, you will notice that there are a lot of options to choose from. Keep the following features in mind and you will be able to find the perfect tray without spending time.

Durability and material

Durability and material are closely related to each other. In fact, durability depends largely on the material of which the mold is made: for example, plastic, although very cheap, is not particularly durable because it tends to be damaged while cubes are being extracted. Silicone is much more durable, not to mention metal, but it costs more.

Presence of lid

The lid is very useful to protect ice cubes from any odors and contamination due to contact with other foods in the freezer. The lids hold the liquid inside the trays, allowing you to reach other objects in the freezer without having to worry about causing damage.

The dimensions

Dimensions vary depending on the amount of ice you need. If you don’t use a lot of them, all you need is a medium-sized mold, instead, if you plan to use them in large quantities, perhaps at a party, better to buy larger molds. Even the dimensions of the individual cubes can vary.

Keep in mind that larger cubes require longer freezing times and vice versa, but on the other hand, they keep the drinks fresh for longer.

The shapes

The most obvious aspect to consider is the shape of the ice cube trays. The shape varies according to the molds. The most traditional is the cube-shaped one, but there are molds with fun shapes designed especially for children. Some ice cube tray shapes are also suitable for making candles, soaps, bath bombs and clay charms, which are heart-warming gifts.

The design

The design of the tray is another aspect to review. If you’re one of those people who love to coordinate every element of their home down to the smallest detail, you’ll be happy to know that ice cube trays come in tons of colors, from clear to shiny and bold.

Plastic, Silicone or Metal?

The material not only affects the durability of the ice tray but also partly on the flavor, smell and shape of the cubes. Let’s analyze the three main materials with which the molds are made in detail:

  • Plastic is the cheapest material but it is also not very durable because it tends to be easily damaged during the extraction of the cubes. Another problem depends on the fact that the plastic tends to absorb the odors from the freezer, transmitting them to the ice.
  • Silicone is better than plastic because it allows you to easily extract the ice cubes without the risk of ruining them. On the other hand, it also absorbs odors by transmitting them to the ice.
  • Metal is by far the best material for ice trays because it lasts a long time, is not easily damaged, allows you to easily extract the cubes and does not release potentially toxic substances, which can happen with some types of plastic trays.

Best Way to Use the Ice Tray

Even if new, the ice tray must be thoroughly washed. If you just bought it, just rinse it with hot water and wipe it with a clean cloth. If it is used, it is better to use dishwashing detergent and hot water, cleaning it thoroughly so as to eliminate traces of ice and various residues.

Baking soda is very useful for removing any bad smells and flavors: 2 teaspoons dissolved in half a glass of hot water are enough to clean the tray, making it like new.

As for the choice of water to be frozen, avoid tap water which sometimes has a bad taste, favoring bottled water or boiled water, leaving it to cool before placing it in the freezer. The tray should be therefore placed on a flat surface so that the cubes are all the same size, preferably at the bottom of the freezer where the temperature is lower.

Conclusion

Regarding the published rankings, the year of publication should always be taken into account. If you work with old charts for Ice Cube Molds, you may not find the best product due to outdated information. Therefore, our last tip: always look for information on the test winner of the current year, in the best case, in combination with a detailed review.

Leave a Comment